Skip to main content

Different Taxation Methods

G
Written by Guido Kaspers
Updated over 2 months ago

Tax is a government-imposed levy added to the cost of goods, services, and transactions to generate revenue. Each country has its own unique and specific tax regulations. These varying details can become quite complex and confusing for retailers aiming to sell various products across multiple countries.


The Different Taxation Methods

The taxes covered in this guide are all forms of indirect taxes. Unlike direct taxes, which are paid directly to the government (such as income tax), indirect taxes are collected at various stages of the supply chain and remitted to the government, typically included in the purchase price of goods or services. There are two main types of consumption taxes, often referred to as value-added tax (VAT) or goods and services tax (GST), depending on the country. These taxes are calculated using a standard percentage set by the importing country's government.

VAT

Most countries utilize VAT as their primary taxation method. The rates, rules, and exceptions for VAT are established at the individual country level. VAT is applied at each stage of a product's production, distribution, and consumption, charged whenever value is added—from the sale of raw materials to the final consumer purchase. Although VAT is collected at each transaction point, a portion reimburses the VAT paid by the previous buyer in the chain, with the government receiving a portion from every stage. Ultimately, the consumer bears the full VAT cost in the final transaction.

GST

GST, or Goods and Services Tax, is another term for VAT used in some countries. It functions similarly to VAT, applying to goods and services at each stage of production and distribution, with the tax included in the final consumer price.

Sales Tax

Another form of indirect tax is the United States (U.S.) sales tax. Unlike most countries that levy VAT or GST, the U.S. uses state sales tax for taxation. Several criteria must be met for sales tax collection to occur. While VAT is paid multiple times at various production, distribution, and consumption stages, sales tax is only charged to the consumer at the point of sale.

U.S. State Sales Tax

Sales tax is a one-time tax applied at the point of purchase. The consumer pays it to the retailer, who then remits it to the government. Only the end consumer pays sales tax. Manufacturers or retailers purchasing items for resale are exempt from paying sales tax on those purchases. Sales tax rates, rules, and exceptions are determined at the local and state levels.

Retailers are not required to collect or remit sales tax on interstate online sales unless they have a business presence (nexus) in the state. Nexus can be established through physical presence (such as buildings, employees, or salesperson visits) or economic presence (meeting sales thresholds set by each state). Retailers must either have a business presence or exceed sales value thresholds within the buyer's state to be obligated to collect and remit sales tax there.

U.S. import sales tax: The U.S. does not have a national sales tax applicable to imports. International (and domestic) sellers are only required to collect and remit sales tax when they have nexus in the state they are selling to.


Comparing Taxation Methods

As previously discussed, VAT/GST and sales tax are indirect taxes, with the end consumer ultimately bearing the cost. These taxes are implemented by governments to generate revenue. However, their differences become particularly relevant in cross-border transactions.

VAT/GST

  • Who Bears the Responsibility for Paying the Tax?

    Taxes are paid at every stage of a product's lifecycle, from production to final sale, whenever value is added.

    The purchaser, whether buying raw materials, wholesale goods, or the final retail product, is required to pay VAT or GST during production, distribution, or consumption, with rates established by the laws of each country.

    Each business involved in these transactions must remit the collected tax to the government.

  • At What Stages Is the Tax Collected from the Consumer?

    The tax is collected at each stage of production, distribution, and consumption.

  • How Does Tax Invoicing Operate?

    The tax amount is typically included in the total purchase price (inclusive). A VAT invoice must be issued within 15 days before the end of the month in which the goods or services were provided. Failure to issue the invoice within the allotted time may result in the illegal imposition of late fees.

  • Who is Accountable for Reporting and Remitting the Tax?

    Depending on the country, VAT and GST are typically reported with the assistance of a tax authority.

    In countries with low-value tax schemes, such as the UK, EU, and Australia, cross-border VAT is usually collected by customs unless it pertains to a low-value shipment.

    International low-value taxes (ILVT) are generally self-reported.

  • Who is Responsible for Collecting Tax on Imported Goods?

    Cross-border VAT is typically collected by customs, though new VAT laws are starting to shift this responsibility. These new regulations require sellers and businesses to collect VAT themselves.

    Domestically, GST/VAT are self-reported, while cross-border GST/VAT continues to be collected by customs.

Sales Tax

  • Who Bears the Responsibility for Paying the Tax?

    The final consumer is the only one who pays sales tax, which is paid directly to the retailer. Cross-border transactions may be exempt if there is no nexus relationship with the consumer's tax jurisdiction.

  • At What Stages Is the Tax Collected from the Consumer?

    The tax is collected from the end consumer at the time of sale.

  • How Does Tax Invoicing Operate?

    Sales tax is calculated based on the products or services listed on the invoice. Unlike VAT/GST, invoice timing for sales tax is typically not legislated, as there is no need to reclaim the taxes. Invoices are generally issued at the point of sale but can also be part of the transaction negotiation process. Businesses should retain invoices from business-to-business (B2B) and business-to-consumer (B2C) transactions for seven years. With rare exceptions, consumers usually don't need to keep invoices or receipts.

  • Who is Accountable for Reporting and Remitting the Tax?

    Sales taxes are typically self-reported by businesses periodically, which can be monthly, quarterly, or yearly. Generally, the higher your sales volume in a state, the more frequently you are required to report.

  • Who is Responsible for Collecting Tax on Imported Goods?

    Sales tax is never collected by customs; if sales taxes are due, sellers typically remit them directly to the applicable states. Sales tax must be self-reported and remitted by the business. Imports to the U.S. from an international seller are generally not charged sales tax unless:

    • Businesses outside the U.S. sell above the threshold in any state (with thresholds and rules varying by state).

    • The business is in the state of the imports (nexus).

    Nexus laws are unique to each state.


Conclusion

While VAT, GST, and sales tax are distinct methods of taxation, they all essentially serve the same purpose. Regardless of whether a country imposes taxes at a set rate, a percentage based on added value, at the time of consumption, during production and distribution, at the point of sale, or at the time of import, all these forms of taxation aim to generate government revenue.

Did this answer your question?